1Department of Biology, University of Rome Tor Vergata, Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 00133 Roma, Italy
2CHOSE–Centre for Hybrid and Organic Solar Energy–University of Rome Tor Vergata, via del Politecnico 1, 00133 Roma, Italy
*Address for Correspondence: Prof. Cinzia Forni, Department of Biology, University of Rome Tor Vergata Via della Ricerca Scientifica, 00133 Rome (Italy), Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Dates: Submitted: 29 September 2017; Approved: 09 October 2017; Published: 11 October 2017
How to cite this article: Rossi M, Matteocci F, Di Carlo A, Forni C. Chlorophylls and xanthophylls of crop plants as dyes for Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells (DSSC). J Plant Sci Phytopathol. 2017; 1: 087-094.
Copyright: © 2017 Rossi M, et al. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Keywords: Chlorophyll; xanthophylls; Dye; DSSCs
Natural dyes have become a viable alternative to expensive and rare organic sensitizers because of their low cost, easy attainability, abundance of supply of raw materials and environmental friendliness. Chlorophyll, the most abundant pigment, can be extracted from plant leaves with simple and inexpensive methods, but it’s difficult to use as a Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells (DSSC) sensitizer due to the absence of OH and COOH groups. The opposite is true for xanthophylls, a particular class of carotenoids that contain free hydroxyl groups and thus may be considered as potential DSSC sensitizers. In this work we describe a new and inexpensive method of chlorophyll extraction from leaves based on the use of a basic solvent that provides the creation of COOH groups, allowing chlorophyll binding on the TiO2 layer. This modified chlorophyll dye showed a higher DSSC efficiency level (0.72%) compared to xanthophylls, which had lower efficiency.
Dye-Sensitized Solar Cells (DSSC) were inspired by the characteristic electron transfer mechanism of photosynthesis. This technology, created by Grätzel , is based on the use of four different components, which, acting simultaneously, generate a regenerative electrochemical process based on a mechanism of electronic injection . The working voltage produced by the cells is the difference between the chemical potential of the electron acceptor (Fermi level) and the redox potential of the electron donor. The electrical circuit is composed by: a dye as a light harvester, a TiO2 layer as an electron acceptor, a iodide/triiodide (I-/I3-) electrolyte as an electron donor and a platinum (Pt) counter-electrode on the cathode. The chemical reactions of the injection mechanism is based on the following three phases: light absorption, electron injection, and regeneration.
DSSC are composed of the following four components: 1) semi-conductor, 2) electrolyte, 3) counter-electrode, 4) dyes . The semi-conductor must have two characteristics in order to be used, i.e. a high dye chemisorption capacity and a high dielectric constant which enables the shielding of the injected electron, avoiding the recombination with the oxidized dye. The most used semiconductor, based on its performances and price, is titanium dioxide (TiO2 or titania) in anatase form. TiO2 shows a high dielectric constant that prevents electron recombination with the dye, and a high refractive index that allows a homogeneous distribution of light within the nanoporous layer.
The electrolyte task provides a new electron to the dye with the aim of restarting the injection cycle of the electron. Cell voltage and current intensity, two parameters which produce the efficiency of the Grätzel cell, are electrolyte-dependent. Usually electrolytes contain I-/I3- redox ions, but there are also bromine electrolytes (Br-/Br2). The reaction that occurs in the electrolyte is: 3I-→I3-+2e-
This reaction provides two electrons that will be used to regenerate the dye. The electrolyte is then regenerated to the counter electrode. The use of electrolytes can present a major disadvantage due to improper cell sealing that causes evaporation, giving an unsuitable cell.
The counter-electrode regenerates the electrolyte, that is why it must have a low resistance to charge transfer and a high density of current exchange. Platinum is the most used material as a counter-electrode, but it is an extremely expensive element. A low cost alternative that deserves to be taken into consideration is carbon.
vThe photosensitive dye is a molecule that absorbs solar radiation, injecting an electron into the semi-conductor conduction band. Every sensitizer must have some particular characteristics: a) absorption in the visible range of light, b) chemisorption on the semi-conductor surface,c) efficient electronic injection into the semi-conductor conduction band, d) carboxyl or hydroxyl groups which can complex the titanium (Ti) on the surface of TiO2, e) a good ability to absorb photons.
Organic dyes, such as ruthenium complexes, or natural organic dyes, in particular flavonoids and anthocyanins, are the most common sensitizers used with this technology [3-6] but chlorophylls and carotenoids can also be used, provided some special precautions are taken . Natural dyes are an excellent alternative to organic compounds. They have all of the basic features of a DSSC dye and, above all, are inexpensive and readily available. Chlorophyll (chl) is the main plant photosynthetic pigment. Photosynthetic organisms have different types of chlorophyll (a, b, c1, c2, c3 and d), but in higher plants only chl-a and chl-b are present . Chl-a and chl-b differ in the molecular structure of a single side chain of the cyclic tetrapyrrole due to the presence of CH3 in chl-a and CHO in chl-b. These two molecules absorb light at different wavelengths; chl-a has two absorption peaks, the first one at 430 nm and the second one at 663 nm; chl-b has absorption peaks at 480 nm and 650 nm.
Chlorophylls can be considered ideal photosensitizers due to a highly stable polycyclic network of alternating single and double bonds (polyenes) conjugated structure, that allows the orbitals delocalization . Nevertheless the presence of alkyl groups in the molecule hinders the efficient binding of these pigments on the nanoporous TiO2 surface . Therefore, most of the literature reports in this field are concerning the use of pure or modified chl molecules [7,10,11]. Beside chl, carotenoids are terpenoid pigments that adsorb light for photosynthesis and protect the photosystems from photo-oxidation. They show an absorption peak near to 470 nm. There are two classes of carotenoids: Carotenes (chemically formed by carbon and hydrogen) and Xanthophylls (chemically formed by carbon, hydrogen and oxygen).
Due to the expensive and sometimes strenuous procedures to obtain natural dye, the aim of this work was to verify the possibility of utilizing crude extracts of chlorophylls and carotenoids from crop species, in order to better use agricultural wastes. For this purpose we chose two important and widely used crops, e.g. spinach (Spinacia oleracea L.) and pepper (Capsicum annuum L.). The chl dye was extracted from leaves of spinach, while a xanthophyll dye was extracted from fruits of pepper. The latter are characterized by the presence of two xanthophylls (xanth), capsantin and capsorubin, that have hydroxyl groups (Figure 1), useful for the bindings on the TiO2 layer.
Preparation of photo-anodes
This preparation consists of different steps. A glass plate spattered with FTO is divided with a laser (Universal laser system ULS 30 Watt) in cells with three photo-anodes; each photo-anode is separated from the others, so as to be electrically isolated. Every photo-anode was printed with a 0.25 mm2 TiO2 nano-particle (diameter 20 nm) layer, and then baked for 2 hours following a temperature ramp: 45 minutes from 100° C to 480° C, 30 minutes at 480°C, 45 minutes from 480°C to 100°C. This process is called sintering and it turns TiO2 in a mesoporous material. A second TiO2 layer is printed above the previous one. This second layer is made with larger TiO2 particles (diameter 400 nm) and then sintered again. The second layer is a scatter layer, and its purpose is to evenly spread the light on the bottom layer.
Preparation of the basic solvent for chlorophyll extraction
The solvent used during the chlorophyll extraction is a methanol-based solvent. A quantity of NaOH equal to 5% (w/v) is added to methanol, and then stirred for 6 hours.
Preparation of the dye: pigment extraction
Chlorophylls (chl) were extracted from fresh or frozen leaves of spinach. 1.5 g (fresh weight) of leaves were homogenized in liquid nitrogen using a mortar and pestel. The powder obtained was suspended in 10 ml of the basic solvent and then stirred at 5°C for 90 minutes. Then the samples were centrifuged 15 minutes at 1500 x g; the supernatants were collected and filtered (0.2 μm pore filters, Whatman) and kept at -20°C until use. Due to chlorophyll photo-sensitivity, all the steps of this protocol were performed under dim light and glassware containing dyes were covered with aluminium foil to minimize photooxidation. The performance of dyes obtained from fresh leaves were compared with those from frozen ones. Moreover, in order to determine the effect of preservation on dye stability, efficiency determinations were carried out with either one day old chlorophyll extracts or with extracts kept for one month at -20°C.
The xanthophyll (xanth) capsantin and capsorubin were extracted from fruits of red pepper ground according to the above described method. The xanth were extracted in methanol.
Dye deposition on photo-anodes
The photo-anodes were heated at 160° C for 10 minutes, in order to eliminate the residual humidity and then dipped into the dye sample and maintained at 4°C for at least 4 hours. After that they were rinsed in ethanol for one minute and cleaned with moist paper to remove any solvent residues from the glass.
The photo-anodes were fixed to the counter electrode with a layer of plastic material called Surlyn (SOLARONIX) and then pressed for 40 s at 100°C. The particular shape of Surlyn allows the creation of three pockets on the layers of TiO2, in which the electrolyte is inserted using a vacuum pump. The cells were then sealed with a sealer (Threebond 3035 B UV resin) to prevent electrolyte evaporation. Finally, a silver paste is used to create cell contacts.
The photo-electrochemical characterization of DSSC is carried out with a sun-simulator (ABET technologies Sun 2000 solar simulator) set at 1 sun light intensity. This characterization gives four output parameters:
• Voc: Open Circuit Voltage, measured in mV.
• Jsc: Short Circuit Photocurrent. Measured in mA/cm2./p>
• FF: Fill Factor, percentage value.
• η: efficiency, percentage value.
Every measurement of the DSSC was performed three times with 9 repetitions. The data are the average of the determinations±E.S.
Preliminary experiments performed using a crude chlorophyll extract were unsuccessful, since the lack of free carboxyl or hydroxyl groups did not allow the binding of the pigment on the TiO2 surface. Chl is characterized by the presence of two ester bonds that link two different substituents, one of them is the phytol group, on the porphyrin ring. The use of a basic solvent (NaOH) allowed the basic hydrolysis of these two bonds, leaving two carboxyl groups on the porphyrin ring, allowing the binding on TiO2 surface (Figure 2).
The basic hydrolysis of chl induced changes in the absortion peaks (Figure 3). The principal bands of chl at 425.1 and 654.9 nm were shifted to 410 and 635 nm for hydrolizyzed chl.
The DSSC sensitized with the hydrolyzed chl showed high efficiency, Voc, Jsc and FF values (Table 1).
In order to detect the effect of preservation on the dye stability, efficiency determinations were carried out with 1 day or 1 month old dyes, maintained as described above. Table 1 shows the difference between old and newly extracted dyes. New dyes were more effective than the old ones, because of the degradation of the chl molecules in the samples. No differences between dyes derived from frozen or fresh leaves were detected (Table 1; Figure 4-7).
DSSC sensitized with xanth dyes showed different values compared to chl ones. Due to the hydroxyl groups of capsantin and capsorubin, the binding on the TiO2 layer surface always occurred, but these two xanthophylls were not effective as DSSC sensitizers. In Table 2 are reported the values obtained with DSSC sensitized with xanthophylls. Xanth. 1, Xanth. 2 and Xanth. 3 represent the three different extractions followed by three different sensitizations. The photo-electrochemical parameters were not significantly (P<0.001) different (Table 2). The values of xanth photo-electrochemical parameters were lower compared to chl DSSC.
The most used DSSC sensitizers are ruthenium compounds and anthocyanin dyes [5,6], since chlorophylls are not usually used as dyes because of the absence of carboxyl or hydroxyl groups preventing the binding to titania [3,12]. This absence requires the use of particular strategies, e.g. a different molecule can be used as a bridge between TiO2 and chlorophyll allowing the binding of the molecule on the TiO2 layer . Usually these strategies are expensive and sometimes they can interfere with the light harvesting, resulting in a low DSSC efficiency. The extraction and the NaOH hydrolyzation procedure of chl described in this work is fast, economic and efficient; moreover due to the basic hydrolysis that provides free carboxylic groups, no different binding strategies are needed. This chl had a higher efficiency value (0.62% average η value) than the unhydrolyzed one obtained from spinach (0.16%) and papaya leaves (0.28%) [13,14] and one of the best of those reported in literature (0.47%  and 0.46%  from spinach). The NaOH hydrolyzed chl shows higher efficiency compared to a KOH hydrolyzed chl (0.002%) [15,16]. If compared to synthetic dyes the bottle neck of chl- based DSSC is still the low efficiency; but if the performance/cost ratio is considered, this DSSC has a major advantage over both Ru-based and synthetic organic ones .
Our results confirm the literature reports about the potentiality of vegetable dyes as sensitizers in DSSCs. Chlorophyll is produced in large quantities from higher plants and it is highly available. From an economic point of view, the best choice may be to fabricate DSSCs with dye sensitizers, produced by simple hydrolysis of chlorophyll molecules extracted from crop plants. Capsantin and capsorubin could be good DSSC sensitizers because of their hydroxyl groups; the latter allow the binding to the TiO2 layer, but these xanthophylls are not high performance sensitizers in comparison to hydrolyzed chlorophyll. This opens new future perspectives about the use of agro-food industrial waste as low-cost sources of sensitizers for DSSC.
The authors are grateful to Prof. Bernard Glick for the critical review of the manuscript and to Dr. Daniele Cecchetti for the elaboration of the chemical structure of chlorophyll. This research did not receive any specific grant from funding agencies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.